Broken Garage Door Panels: Should You Replace 1 or All?
Deciding whether to replace or repair the garage depends on a lot of factors but the easiest way to tell is by how badly the door is damaged.
If only a couple of panels have been damaged it will probably be more cost-effective to replace the garage door panels than the entire door. Here are a couple of other things to consider when deciding between the two options.
The Door’s Age
With proper maintenance and care, garage doors can last between 20 and 30 years. If your door is reaching its end of life, it might be best to replace the entire garage door. Newer doors that are 10 years old or less can be suitable for garage door panel replacements, but it might be difficult to find your door panel’s exact color, model and material.
The Extent and Type of Damage
Sometimes, the extent of damage to your garage door warrants a complete door replacement. For example, strong winds can cause large objects to hit the door, causing irreparable damage. In this case, the best option would be to replace the entire garage door.
If the damage is minor and only on one or two panels, replacing only those panels will likely be sufficient to get your garage door looking great again. However, it is still a good idea to have a professional inspect the rest of the door for damage to ensure the door’s structural integrity isn’t compromised.
The Door’s Layout and Design
If you’re thinking about replacing one or more panels, consider your door’s layout and design. Depending on your garage door’s age, its design may be obsolete. Using panels that don’t quite match your door could make them look out of place rather than blending in naturally with the rest of the panels.
Can I Replace the Garage Door Panels Only?
You can replace individual or multiple panels instead of the complete door, but the door should be well maintained to consider replacement. For example, an old, worn door may show signs of deterioration, such as peeling and flaking. You could replace the affected panels, but you will likely notice a style and color mismatch as the new panels stand out from the old ones.
Risks of Replacing Individual Garage Door Panels
Replacing individual garage door panels instead of the entire door has a few inherent risks to consider.
Internal Damage
You may not see it, but your garage door could have internal damage that impacts other components, such as the springs, rails or hinges. These components hold the garage door in place and contribute to its sturdiness. Replacing one panel won’t fix the internal damage. At the very least, the other components should also be repaired or replaced. The best solution, though, might be an entirely new garage door.
Functionality
Replacing a single panel might impact the door’s functionality. For example, even if just one panel is dented, the entire door must be checked to make sure it is still straight and properly aligned on the tracks. If the panel is replaced, but the door isn’t straight, the issue is not entirely solved.
Aesthetics
A newly replaced individual panel can be noticeable among older panels, detracting from your home’s curb appeal. Design limitations may also prevent you from replacing individual or multiple panels, leaving you with two options — replacing all the panels or the entire garage door.
How Much Does Replacing Garage Door Panels Cost?
A single garage door panel replacement can range from $200-$700 depending on the model. Like everything in life, the cost of replacing versus repairing a damaged panel is going to be a significant consideration. Repairing the panel is almost always the more affordable option, and with the help of our team at AAA Garage Doors, your repaired panel can often look as good as new. On the other hand, if your garage door is past its prime and the panels are damaged, then it might just make more financial sense to replace the entire garage door.
Although in the long run, getting your garage door panels replaced might save you money because you won’t be paying maintenance costs as often. With a new Omaha garage door, you will have to call our repair technicians at AAA Garage Doors less often, your home will be kept more secure, and you can enjoy some of the mod-cons that many newer garage doors now come with, such as energy efficiency options, smart technology, and sensors.
Can I Replace Garage Door Panels On My Own?
It’s possible to replace your garage door panels yourself, but we advise against it for several reasons. It’s a complex process that requires special tools and expertise. The door’s weight is another factor, and incorrectly handling it can cause damage to the door and its components. You risk injuring yourself, too.
We recommend contacting a professional garage door contractor to replace the panels for the best results.
How to Match Your Garage Door Panel When Replacing/Repairing
- The first thing you’ll want to do is tell your garage door repair company who the manufacturer of the garage door is and they’ll be able to contact them to see if they have any spare parts. It might be possible to get a matching piece to your garage door.
- You could re-paint the garage door panel that doesn’t match the rest of your garage. There are paints specifically made for exterior doors. Make sure to ask your garage door technician which type of paint is best for your garage door material.
Discuss Your Garage Door Panel Replacement Requirements With AAA Garage Door
Before attempting to replace your garage door panels, speak to our experts at AAA Garage Door for advice on a suitable option. Replacing individual garage door panels works well in many situations, but in some instances, replacing the entire door may be better. We’ll consider various factors to put your mind at ease and find a solution that suits your situation and budget. Call us at 402-307-8013 or request our services online today.
Learn About Garage Door Panel Replacement
Felipe Pinales
Reviewed By: Felipe Pinales - Felipe is Nebraska’s first IDEA-certified Master Technician. He has been employed by AAA Garage Door for 6+ years, and has had the Master Technician Certification in his sights since he began. Felipe has also passed four written examinations including Residential Installer Certification, Commercial Sectional Door Systems Technician Certification, Commercial Rolling Door Systems Technician Certification, and Rolling Steel Fire Door Technician Certification. Felipe is constantly looking for ways to improve his abilities within our industry. His goal is to become the best garage door technician possible to best assist his customers and fellow co-workers.