Wood vs. Steel Garage Doors
A garage door is a long-term investment — you see and use it every day and need to be confident that you can rely on it to protect your vehicle, home and family. Some of the most popular materials used to manufacture garage doors are wood and steel. The material you choose depends on your budget, style preferences and more. Whether you are considering extending a single garage to fit another car, want a detached garage, or need to replace or upgrade your current door, the selection process requires some thought and research.
There are a few factors to consider when choosing between steel vs. wood garages. We’ll walk you through these different factors and the associated pros and cons of wood garages and steel garages to help you determine which is ideal for your needs.
Table of Contents
- Curb Appeal
- Insulation Needs
- AAA Garage Door Has Every Garage Door Solution You Need
Cost is likely one of the first things you’ll consider — do you want to get the best value for your money, are you able to splurge on quality, or are you willing to spend more to achieve a certain look? Here are some pros and cons of steel garages vs. wood garages related to costs:
- Wood garage doors: Wood garage doors are generally more expensive than steel garage doors. Different factors will affect the cost of wood garage doors, including the type of wood and the size of your door. For example, hardwood is heavier and will cost more to install. However, if you love the look of wood doors, you have some options, including faux wood garage doors made from steel with a wood finish. These doors are more affordable and give the look of a wooden door.
- Steel garage doors: Steel garage doors can vary in price, depending on the size of your door, the number of steel layers, the type of insulation and the design style. Customization can add to the overall cost.
Another cost you’ll want to consider is the cost of acquiring a permit to install a new or replacement door. Permit laws will vary by state and municipality but are in place whether you are installing a wood or steel garage door.
Your garage door is a major part of your home, and you want it to be eye-catching. The great thing about both steel and wood garage doors is that they come in various colors and styles. You can experiment with colors and customize your doors to your taste and liking. Here’s how wood and steel garage doors can impact your home’s curb appeal:
- Wood garage doors: Wood garage doors are an elegant addition to any home. The natural grains and texture of wood can’t be replicated so you won’t find any other door like yours.
- Steel garagedoors: Steel doors offer a more modern look, though it depends on the finishing you choose. White and grey garage doors complement the other colors in your home, black garage doors look sleek and sophisticated, and bold colors like red could attract more attention to your home.
If you’re considering building a detached garage, your priority might be space and size rather than insulation and energy savings. However, you may want to consider insulation if your garage is attached to your home. Insulated garage doors can help reduce energy bills by keeping your home cool during the summer and warm during the winter. Compare wood and steel garage doors in terms of insulation:
- Wood garagedoors: Wood is organic and a great natural insulator. Wood garage doors can keep your internal temperature regulated during the summer and winter months. This is ideal for garages that are attached to the home.
- Steel garage doors: A detached garage may not necessarily need insulation if it’s being used primarily for storage. Installing an uninsulated steel garage door could save you money. However, if you’re looking for a steel door for your attached garage, you’ll likely want to choose an insulated option. The two main types of insulation used in steel garage doors are polystyrene and polyurethane. Polystyrene is the more affordable option but is also less effective. You can customize the level of insulation based on your home’s needs.
An important factor in choosing a garage door is its durability. You want peace of mind knowing it can protect you from hazards like fire, storms and wind. Consider the durability of wood vs. steel doors:
- Wood garagedoors: Many types of wood are naturally durable, so your door will likely withstand most weather conditions. However, wood is somewhat susceptible to damage or rot from fire, water and insects if it is not properly maintained. You can help prevent damage, chips and cracks through maintenance tasks like applying waterproof paint to your door, but doing so may be time-consuming.
- Steel garage doors: Steel is extremely durable. It is fire-proof and resistant to warping, severe weather and cracking, making steel garage doors an excellent choice for many homeowners. Steel doors also require much less maintenance to maintain their effectiveness.
Your family’s safety and security are nonnegotiable, so you need to be sure that the garage door you install will effectively protect your home and family. Both wood and steel garage doors can provide the security you need:
- Wood garagedoors: Many people perceive wood garage doors as being less secure since wood is less resilient than other materials. While they may not be as secure as materials like steel, wooden garage doors are very heavy, which adds to their protectiveness.
- Steel garage doors: Security is a major pro of steel garages. Steel garage doors are strong and difficult to force open, offering better protection for your home.
Many consumers are mindful of their carbon footprint and want to contribute to a more sustainable environment. If eco-friendliness is important to you, you may want to install a garage door that’s made of natural materials and can be recycled. Here are the pros and cons of steel garages and wood garages in terms of environmental friendliness:
- Wood garagedoors: One of the pros of wood garages is that their organic composition makes them ideal for recycling at the end of their life span. Wood is also a sustainable building material.
- Steel garage doors: Steel garage doors can be a sustainable choice if they are made of recycled materials. Plus, insulated steel garage doors are energy-efficient, increasing their eco-friendliness.
AAA Garage Door Has Every Garage Door Solution You Need
If you’re still trying to decide which garage door to choose, AAA Garage Door has a solution for you. With a huge selection of garage doors, we will help you find the perfect fit.
Faux Wood vs. Wood Garage Doors
Your garage door is one of the first things guests and strangers notice when they look at the exterior of your house. It may be prominent for different reasons, but it essentially reflects your unique taste and style.
Whether you’re replacing a broken or faulty garage door or upgrading your current one for added aesthetic appeal, you have countless options to choose from. Faux wood garage doors and real wood garage doors come in various designs and colors, giving you the freedom to personalize them as you please.
The challenge is deciding which is better suited to your needs. We’ll discuss the different features and the benefits of both to help you make an informed decision.
Table of Contents
- Faux Wood Garage Door Features
- Wood Garage Door Features
- Benefits of Faux Wood Garage Doors
- Benefits of Wood Garage Doors
- Additional Factors
- Which Is Right for You? Let AAA Garage Doors Help You Decide
Faux Wood Garage Door Features
You’d never know the difference if you see a faux wood garage door from afar. They look exactly like a wood garage door. The only way you’d be able to tell them apart is by knocking on their surface. Wood-like garage doors resemble real ones but are made of materials like fiberglass, steel and aluminum. Each of these materials makes a distinct sound that will reveal the true nature of the faux wood door. The external layer is made of a blend of real timber, softwood and other wood compounds to give it a natural look.
Wood Garage Door Features
Real wood garage doors are exquisite and unmatched in beauty, though they can easily be mistaken for faux wood garage doors. Most are manufactured using layers of hardwood rather than traditional solid wood. The one thing that sets them apart from faux wood is the texture and color variation of real wood, which is something that cannot be replicated. The grains and patterns in real wood add depth and character that distinguishes it from wood-like garage doors.
You’re also able to install custom wooden garage doors by choosing from an array of different wood types like oak, mahogany, cedar and reclaimed wood. You can add panels, frames and windows that highlight its uniqueness and charm to add your desired personal touch.
Benefits of Faux Wood Garage Doors
Depending on what you have in mind, the benefits of faux wood doors could make it hard for you to choose. There are a few things to consider:
- Cost and value: Wood substitutes cost less to manufacture, purchase and install, depending on your desired material. Aluminum is generally cheaper than the rest and offers value for money since it is exceptionally resistant to rust and corrosion. Adding insulation will increase the value as it helps regulate your home’s temperature while reducing energy bills.
- Appearance: There is almost no distinction between faux wood and real wood garages. Therefore its appearance and curb appeal are equally attractive to its solid wood counterpart.
- Weight: Lifting an aluminum or fiberglass garage door versus a real wood door requires less effort since the wood-like alternative is made of lighter material. This also means the opener will experience less strain when opening and closing, ensuring it operates optimally for longer.
- Maintenance: Maintenance is kept to a minimum with a faux wood door because the material used is able to withstand elements that lead to warping, fading, cracking and rotting. Routine maintenance is still required, although less frequently.
- Durability: Materials like steel are known for their durability against the destructive effects of strong wind, rain and other weather elements.
- Life span: Faux wood garage doors can last decades if maintained well, which adds to their value since they are less costly than wood doors.
These faux wood garage door pros certainly make choosing that much harder.
Benefits of Wood Garage Doors
Considering the same factors when deciding on wood vs. faux wood garage doors indicates your choice. These include:
- Cost and value: Real wood doors are costly, especially if you opt for solid wood like oak or cedar. Customizing it with panels, windows and other features will increase the installation cost. The upside is that you will enjoy a tailored garage door like no other. As with faux wood doors, insulating your wood door will increase your home’s value.
- Appearance: Despite being hard to differentiate from wood-like garage doors, real wood doors have inherent qualities that enhance their beauty and style. This can’t be achieved in any other way than by using natural wood, adding unparalleled curbside appeal and elegance.
- Maintenance: Your wood door is more likely to undergo regular maintenance because wood is prone to water damage, cracking, rotting and chipping over time and under harsh conditions. Maintenance includes lubricating moving parts, balancing the door properly and checking that the auto-reverse feature is functional. Regardless of whether it is a wood-like or real wood door, keeping your hand on your garage door ensures its longevity and safety for those who use it.
- Durability: Wood in itself is durable in nature, so it should withstand extreme weather for an extended period.
- Life span: A real wood garage door is expected to last up to 30 years if it is well-maintained. However, its organic nature leaves it predisposed to wear and tear over time, which could mean replacing it sooner than later. However, this should not deter you if you are leaning towards a wood garage door.
Given the substantial benefits, the wood garage door pros listed may not make your decision any easier.
While the benefits mentioned before might affect your decision to choose one or the other, there are a few other considerations to bear in mind that may be helpful. They are:
- Climate: While we may experience mid-to-hot weather in the Nebraskan summer with high levels of humidity, winters get extremely cold, with temperatures dwindling in the negative perimeter. Be mindful of this when installing a wood vs faux garage door. Consider the advantages of each in terms of durability and maintenance.
- Increased home value: If you upgrade or replace your garage door, your home’s value will likely increase if you decide to sell. An aesthetically appealing door will certainly secure a higher return on investment, especially if it offers additional benefits.
- Eco-friendliness: If you are conscientious about the environment and ways to keep it safe, you would probably opt for a wood garage door. It is an eco-friendly alternative to materials like steel and aluminum.
These additional points may be the ultimate deciding factor between choosing to install a faux garage door or a real wood garage door. It all comes down to your personal requirements, budget, preferences and specific needs.
Which Is Right for You? Let AAA Garage Doors Help You Decide
Whether you opt for a wood vs faux wood garage door, we have everything you need to perfect your home with the ideal door. If you’re still unsure, our door imagination system will give you a visual aid to show you exactly how each door you try will suit your home. All you need to do is upload a picture of your house to give you an accurate representation.
What are you waiting for? Submit a contact request form, and we’ll get in touch with you shortly.
7 Things to Consider When Deciding on a Garage Door
Replacing a garage door is not an annual or even biannual investment. Instead, garage doors are designed to last for years on end and are expected to be in use for anywhere from 15 to 30 years. This means you may be unfamiliar with what to look for and consider when searching for a replacement. From material to insulation, there is a lot to keep in mind when finding the perfect fit for your home.
To help you make a better-educated decision, we compiled a list of seven things to consider when deciding on a new garage door. Keep reading to learn more.
Is It Time to Replace or Buy a New Garage Door?
A garage door opens 1,500 times on average every year. Because they are used so frequently, they endure a great amount of wear and tear that impacts their functionality.
Signs it is time to buy a new garage door:
- Dents and damages: Having a dinged-up garage door can be more than a cosmetic issue. Cracks and rotting in the panels of a door can negatively affect everything from insulation to functionality.
- Age: How long a garage door will last depends on maintenance, use, and other factors. It is generally suggested to replace your garage doors after about 15 years.
- Mechanical issues: When your garage door breaks down repeatedly, consider buying a replacement. If sensors fail to work or your door is crooked, it is likely time for something new.
- Inefficient: If your garage door is not insulated or it is inefficient in some way, you may want to explore other options that will save you money on energy costs.
- Noises: A garage door should not wake up the neighborhood when it is opened and closed. If your door repeatedly makes strange noises, it is likely time to start looking for a garage door replacement.
- Style: A garage door contributes to the curb appeal and the overall design of a house. If your garage door looks outdated, it may be time for a new one.
7 Things to Consider When Deciding on a New Garage Door
Before making a purchase for your new garage door, review the following factors that will impact your choice!
1. Security and Door Openers
For homeowners, having a secure garage door is especially important. A secure garage door will keep out unwanted visitors like wild animals and thieves. Having a door opener is a great convenience, but choosing the right one can be confusing.
For optimal protection, find an opener that works with a rolling code. These are harder for hackers to figure out and provide an extra level of security.
Garage doors are heavy and involve machinery that can be dangerous if the door is not operating properly. A malfunction or safety concern may be your reason for searching for a new garage door.
There are a few safety-related features to consider while shopping. Having properly functioning sensors is crucial since these need to be properly aligned to operate and they reduce accidents by sensing people and pets below the door, keeping it from closing on them.
Before buying, consider what material or materials you want your new garage door to be made from as this will affect other factors like price and style. There are some common materials including:
- Wood composites
The material you choose will require different levels of maintenance. Your garage door’s materials will also impact how long the door will last before needing a replacement. For example, natural wood doors require a lot more maintenance than steel doors.
Something you may overlook when considering a new garage door is insulation. Having insulated garage doors helps save energy by keeping the garage warmer. The two materials used by manufacturers for insulation are polyurethane or polystyrene. Doors with polyurethane are rated by R-values in which the highest value is the best insulation. This rating system starts at 6.3 and goes through 20.4. The higher values are also related to higher savings on energy.
5. Price Point
For most homeowners, a garage door is an investment expected to last for years. There are a few factors that should be considered that will impact the price point. These factors include:
- Material: The price will change depending on the door’s composition. Fiberglass and steel, for example, are typically cheaper than natural wood models.
- Insulation: Choosing an insulated door will add costs. Each layer of insulation will contribute to higher prices.
- Style: Different style garage doors will cost different amounts of money, whether it is an aesthetic or mechanical difference.
- Technology: Any door opener or other technology you decide to pair with your new garage door will cost you more, but can be– worth the extra money for security and convenience.
- Installation fees: When choosing the perfect garage door for your home, do not forget to factor in installation costs because having your door professionally installed is always preferable.
The style of garage door you choose will likely depend on the design style of your home. When it comes to the looks of the doors, everyone has a personal preference and taste. Consider the different types of doors and how they function as well before landing on a model. There are a few choices including:
- Roll-up: This type of door includes several smaller parts connected to one larger unit that rolls overhead into the garage to open the door.
- Tilt-up: In a single panel, this type of door opens and closes in one piece with a ceiling-mounted track.
- Sectional: Similar to a roll-up door, this style typically has three or four panels linked by hinges.
7. Professional Installation
Having your garage door professionally installed is always suggested. A garage door needs to be safely positioned and installed to lessen the chances of injury and malfunction. Professionals not only have the experience to properly install the door, but they also have the right tools for the job. Oftentimes, warranties for garage doors require them to be professionally installed.
Other Resources For Garage Door Buyers
- How Much Value Does a New Garage Door Add?
- 4 Benefits of a New Garage Door
- How to Choose The Right Garage Style?
- Garage Door Replacement Services
Get Your New Garage Door From AAA Garage Door
Deciding on the right garage door for your home can feel a bit overwhelming without any guidance. Finding the perfect fit for your needs and preferences can be easier with this list of seven things to consider when deciding on a new garage door.
If you are in the market for a replacement garage door, AAA Garage Door can help. Equipped with over 25 years of experience and a customer-driven approach, we can provide you with high-quality products and installation services.
Request an estimate for a new garage door from AAA Garage Door today!
Does a Garage Increase Home Value?
Your garage is one of the first features passersby notice when they view your home. A garage door may stand out prominently or blend in, depending on the color, size and style. It is a relatively affordable measure of ensuring your home attracts attention if you’re in the market to sell.
Read on to learn more about how much value a garage door can add to your home, ways it can increase your home’s appraisal and more. Partner with AAA Garage Door to upgrade your garage door and see how much it enhances your home’s curb appeal and worth.
How Much Value Does a New Garage Door Add to My Home?
According to Remodeling’s updated 2023 Cost and Value Report, there are various ways to secure a return on your investment by making home improvements. A garage door replacement ranks among the highest returns, with an estimated 102.7% cost recovery upon resale. Based on their national averages, replacing a garage door could cost up to $4,302, but you’ll get $4,415 back when you sell your home. Hence, garage door ROI is one of the most profitable gains.
The West North Central report averages differ slightly from the regional city report mentioned above, with a somewhat lower cost recoup amount of 78% compared to 102%. It is still significant compared to other home improvement projects that may seem to provide a greater return but offer less in resale value. Examples include roofing replacement at 42%, bathroom remodeling at 41%, major kitchen remodeling at 40%, deck addition at 38% and an upscale primary suite addition at 20%.
5 Ways a New Garage Door Increases Your Home’s Value
A residential garage door style that matches your home will likely add value in numerous ways. Your bottom-line resale price depends on the cost of installing a new door and its aesthetic appeal. Generally, the more you spend, the higher ROI you can expect. The new owners will appreciate the money and effort you put in — a benefit any prospective buyers should consider.
We’ve listed a few ways a new garage door can increase your home’s value that may help convince you to install one.
1. Increased Energy Efficiency
Most new garage doors have insulation and other high-quality materials that make them energy efficient, helping you save money in the long run. With the right insulation R-value, your garage door can regulate temperatures year-round.
You could save money on your energy bills with a well-insulated garage door, like one reinforced with numerous steel layers or made of polystyrene and polyurethane. Your HVAC system takes less strain when you don’t have to use it as frequently to heat or cool your living spaces, like rooms adjacent to your garage. Insulation keeps the cold air out in the winter while keeping the interior comfortable during summer.
2. Improved Door Durability
A new garage door consists of durable material that lasts many years. They often have aluminum or steel frames reinforced with internal polystyrene or polyurethane insulation. These doors offer more protection and durability, which will increase your home’s value through added security. New doors are less prone to damage from dents and don’t warp as easily.
You can expect your garage door to last up to 30 years if it doesn’t sustain severe damage from storms and adverse weather and you maintain it regularly. Wear and tear are inevitable, but you can minimize damage by having any dents repaired by a professional garage door contractor before they worsen. Fortunately, new doors carry a limited warranty that will cover damages for a specific period after you initially install it.
3. Less Maintenance
A new garage door costs less to maintain than an older one. Over time, worn components may start deteriorating and need replacing. The paint may also start peeling and chipping, leaving you with an eyesore. Though you can repaint it and replace the panels, these cosmetic fixes won’t have the same effect as a new garage door, especially to interested buyers who may perceive these as attempts to conceal its imperfections.
With an upgraded garage door, the people who buy your home will have peace of mind knowing they won’t have to install a new one for a long time, and they’re more likely to consider paying your full asking price if it saves them down the line.
4. Improved Curb Appeal
Your garage door’s appearance is essential if you’re considering ways to increase your home’s value. It should have at least three elements that make it stand out to improve the curb appeal.
- Customization: Your new garage door should enhance your house’s exterior by adding a modern, rustic or traditional touch based on your existing home style.
- Material: Sturdy materials like steel, solid wood or aluminum influence the value, durability and strength.
- Color: Choosing similar, bold or contrasting colors will complement your home, making it more attractive.
5. Modern Safety Features
Modern technology allows you to control newly installed garage doors with your smartphone, so you can set them to open and close automatically, monitor activity remotely and change the security codes as you wish. Most have an auto-reverse safety feature that prevents the door from closing on any person or object.
These garage door improvements will give potential buyers confidence, which an older door might not offer.
How Much Is a New Garage Door?
A new garage door can cost thousands of dollars, but you get what you pay for. Custom doors like carriage and French styles that meet specific requirements are pricey, though you can find more affordable options to suit any budget. Consider factors like whether you need a single or double garage, insulation, material and door opener types — these will all impact your price.
How Often Should You Replace Your Garage Door?
A new, well-maintained garage door should last a long time. If you experience a severe thunderstorm or accident that causes significant damage, you might have to repair or replace it. Preventive maintenance ensures you get maximum value and longevity for your money.
Get the Best Garage Door Resale Value With AAA Garage Door
Installing a new garage door has advantages. One of these is the ROI you can expect when selling your home. At AAA Garage Door, you can count on us to deliver outstanding service using the highest-quality material to install the garage door you need.